Blog For Free!
Archives
Home
2008 July
2008 June
2008 May
2008 April
2008 March
2008 January
2007 December
2007 November
2007 October
2007 September
2007 August
2007 July
2007 June
2007 March
2007 February
2006 October
2006 September
2006 August
2006 July
2006 June
2006 May
2006 April
2006 March
2006 February
2006 January
2005 December
2005 October
2005 September
2005 August
2005 July
2005 June
2005 May
2005 April
2005 March
2005 February
2005 January
2004 December
2004 November
2004 October
2004 September
2004 August
2004 July
2004 June
2004 May
2004 April
2004 March
My Links
Canadawide
Juan Cole
TPM
Daily Dish
CanucksCathie
E-Group
vanramblings
peace order and good government
Calgary Grit
True North
Gwynn Dyer
Public eye
declan
Sean
Progressive Blogs
Voice in the Wilderness
Tilting at windmills
sec 15
tyee
one damn thing after another
Antonia Zerbisias
Buckets of Grewal
Blank out Times
Accidental Deliberations
Heartlands
Rick Mercer
buckets too
Amazing wonderdog
The Maple Three
The Hive
Cindy Silver 7
Cindy Silver 6
Cindy Silver 5
Cindy Silver 4
Cindy Silver 3
Cindy Silver 2
Cindy Silver
Cindy Silver Sum
Cindy Silver 9
Cindy Silver PR
Cindy Silver (blogs Canada)
Cindy Silver (Blogs Canada 2)
Liberal Blogs
tBlog
My Profile
Send tMail
My tFriends
My Images
Sponsored
Blog
| Fallujah, Juan Cole and Intellectual Dishonesty |
| 04.28.04 (11:33 pm) [edit] |
|
Juan Cole is at it again. “It does not matter that some Fallujans are trying to kill Marines. You cannot punish the entire city for that. … Although about 1/3 of Fallujans have reportedly left the city, that would leave 200,000 or so inside.” If I wanted to be an ass, I would say that they are being collectively punished because they are collectively guilty. However, the fact of the matter is that the city as a whole is not being “punished”. The fighting as a whole has been fairly localized and by pointing out that 200,000 are still left in the city Cole is being deliberately deceptive. The majority of those in the combat zones have fled. Another thing that is particular irksome is that while Cole and others stress the number of combatants to give the impression that the US is using “a jack hammer to crack a walnut” and that the rest of population is completely without guilt, they invariably fail to mention the large number of people connected to the guerrillas in some form. Such a policy is direct contrast of to his usual policy of debunking the ridiculous claims of Rumsfeld and others that the insurgency is limited to terrorists and thugs. Indeed this is what Juan Cole said in regard to claims that Sadr ‘only has 10,000 militia men under his command. “In fact that is the size of his formal militia. Muqtada's movement is like the layers of an onion. You have 10,000 militiamen. But then you have tens of thousands of cadres able to mobilize neighborhoods. Then you have hundreds of thousands of Sadrists, followers of Muqtada and other heirs of Muhammad Sadiq al-Sadr." Yet another form of intellectual dishonestly engaged in by Cole is to say that what is happening to Fallujah is an extreme response to what happened to those four contractors. This is ridiculous. The Americans did not go into Fallujah because of what happened to the contractors. Fallujah has been a source of trouble for over a year now and what happened to the contractors was the proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back. |
| 0 Comments |